[Aw yeah, still got it.

He smiles in response to Cater's, but it's much less... Friendly. He kind of smiles like he has terrible news and he's excited to talk about it.]

So you're weak, now? Lost your magic, what makes your life so much easier, and now you're left to struggle and learn how to adapt without it? How sad. Does it make you upset?

[Heh.]

Are you afraid you won't get it back? That it's been stripped from you forever? You'll only have yourself, now. Just one of you, all alone.